When a Stranger Calls

Audience Reviews

View More

Brian L. @Brian91 Jun 19 Listen I don't understand all the hate this movie gets. The ratings on this movie are crazy, I might be crazy but I really did enjoy this movie when it came out. I was in high-school at the time, so to me I really enjoyed it. I have never seen the original movie, so I can't speak on that one. But as far as this one goes I thought it was really good. Is it the greatest movie ever made? No, but for a very simple concept that it is. It's done very good. Just my opinion, don't attack me lol. See more Blake- N @PBSAniDom Apr 27 When When a Stranger Calls (remake) feels less like its own story and more like a shallow mix of ideas borrowed from films like Phone Booth and American Psycho. Instead of building real suspense, it relies on recycled tension and surface-level shock value without any of the originality or psychological depth those films delivered. The result is a bland, forgettable thriller that never earns its scares. By contrast, the 1979 original is far more effective, using restraint and atmosphere to create genuine unease, and remains the superior version. It understands simplicity and tension in a way the remake completely misses. Overall, the remake is a disappointing 0/10, while the 1979 film earns a solid 6/10 for its classic suspense and straightforward execution. See more Sarah M @RT84798007 Mar 16 I like this movie a lot for the plot. It’s simple, yet effective! Good watch if you need something to watch with the boyfriend/gf. Love it! See more Trevor S @PopcornPopper Feb 5 It hit different watching it as a teenager. It’s a great film for viewers with little to no thriller/horror watching. A good beginner chill and thrill. See more Daniel L @Hotchopeppa Jan 19 Really like this remake. No idea why it has such terrible scores. It's well made and well written. Plus Camilla Belle is crazy hot as the babysitter. See more TheMovieSearch R @TheMovieSearch Dec 30 When a Stranger Calls is a remake that has been unfairly dismissed over the years. While it doesn’t reinvent the premise, it understands the power of simplicity and atmosphere. The fear here isn’t monsters or gore, but isolation, silence, and the terrifying idea that someone is already inside your home. That concept alone carries much of the tension. The film does a solid job building unease through long stretches of quiet, eerie phone calls, and the growing realization that the threat is closer than expected. The direction is restrained, sometimes to a fault, but it allows suspense to simmer instead of relying on nonstop jump scares. The screenplay could have used sharper escalation and a few stronger payoffs, as some moments feel like missed opportunities. Still, the movie remains effective because it feels plausible. Home invasion horror hits differently when it feels real, and this film leans into that realism. Performances are serviceable See more Read all reviews

When a Stranger Calls

My Rating

Read More Read Less WRITE A REVIEW EDIT REVIEW POST RATING